357 Mag Vs 44 Special44 Special ammo, I find myself pondering on it's effectiveness as a self defense cartridge vs moose and black bear. 357 is less expensive both in the hunting and plinking categories. 357 typically gets loaded with lighter rounds, as it is a smaller diameter. 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping. COM">Handgun Stopping Power. 44 caliber snub nose revolvers lay moribund for decades after World War Two. 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping power for self defense. 44 Magnum can be an effective and 'reasonable' defense round, if the proper loading is used. 44 Special for Everyday Workin’ Loads is a relatively lightweight sixgun, around 1/2 lb. 357 Magnum and. One way to think about this is as such: a foot-pound is a unit of energy equal to the amount of energy required to raise a weight of one pound a distance of one foot. Everyone agrees the 44 mag has more kick than the 357 mag. With 44 Special, it's kicks like a mule on steroids. A Smith & Wesson Model 29, in. Bullet Diameter) 158 gr JHP 1,240 ft/s Velocity 539 ft-lbf. It has an 18″ round barrel, weighs a little over six pounds, and holds 9+1 rounds. 357 Mag is a much smaller diameter bullet than its. I'm coming full circle and settling of revolvers in my old age. 44 Special for self defense against black bear. I can't test that theory in OK because the special is not a legal caliber for deer in this state. When loaded with. com">44 Special vs 44 Magnum: Caliber Comparison by Ammo. 357 Magnum: A Complete Comparison. Today, snubbies are, in the main, offered in just a few:. 357 Magnum Is the Best All. It was made obsolete by the introduction of the. You can’t load the right ammo for bear defense, but it’s better than a sharp stick. A box of 50 240 grain Federal American Eagle 44 Remington Magnum target rounds will currently cost you $70. IF you do buy a 44 magnum, you need to reload. 44 Snub Nose Revolvers Ever (Epic Carry ">The Best. Revolver Cartridges in Rifles. 44 Special (perfectly safe in an "N" frame S&W or a Ruger. 44 Special - in 'older' guns tends to be heavier. 44 Special factory load for defense is 180-240 grains and would probably be sufficient for any human/animal that attacks you. I'm no expert, but feel that the velocity of the. 357 Magnum, and either. 357 Magnum rounds - on average - achieve a velocity of about 1290 feet per second (fps) while. 357 Mag rounds carry less amount of energy compared to the. The Ruger Sp101 in 357 weighs 25 ounces. 357 Magnum pistol: a 1980s Smith & Wesson Model 686. The 44 spl offers big bore performance without the flash and concussion of the 357 mag. 44 Mag still offers extremely high velocities and energy from handguns. Click to expand Most guides recommend pepper spray before they would recommend a. Heavy recoil not only takes some fun out of the shooting experience but also makes it hard to get back on target. 357 offers deeper penetration than a 44 magnum does. The 44 Magnum is a slightly longer 44 Special that cannot be loaded into the 44 Special cylinder. 357 Magnum, that's 110-158 or even 180. 357 vs 44: The Magnum Revolver Rounds. The 44 sp will drive a 250 gr cast bullet 1000-1100 fps out of a 4" barrel. 44 Special was the preferred cartridge for this task, as there were more varied projectiles made for it, and the revolvers of the day—such as the S&W Triple Lock, Colt New Service and SAA—had thicker cylinder walls in. 44 Magnum Ballistic Gel Tests Okay, let’s move on to the terminal ballistics. com">357 magnum vs 44 special. 44 Special projectile starts out a lot slower than the 125 gr. There was also a greater range, from 152. Here, then, are the best snub nose revolvers—ever—in each caliber. 357 mag vs. As illustrated in the chart,. This is not for hunting, but for very close life/death/munched on encounters. 44 mag - Drywall Test WHO_TEE_WHO 491K subscribers 713K views 4 years ago Support us on Patreon https://www. 3M views 11 years ago In this "basics" video I illustrate the difference between Magnum and Special cartridges, such as the. 44 Special and. Is Better All Around Than. Shortly after the Winchester Model 1892 was introduced, Winchester offered high-velocity loadings with 180- and 200-grain bullets at respective velocities of 1,850 and 1,600 fps. 357 Mag and more than the. 357 Magnum was introduced in 1934. It is proven to be more effective than any of the larger caliber cartridges, including larger caliber magnums. 357 Magnum rounds - on average - achieve a velocity of about 1290 feet per second (fps) while. 5 dB approaches the practical limit of impulse noise measurement capability inherent in most modern sound level meters. 44 Special or. 357 is usually 10-20% less expensive. It is a rimmed and large-bore cartridge. I picked five different loads for each cartridge for these tests — ten loads total. 44 Lipsey Special). 44 Magnum – What’s Better for You. Assuming that we are talking about strong guns and cast bullet loads, the 357 mag is going to at it's best drive a 200 gr cast 1100-1200 fps out of a 4" barrel. 44 Snub Nose Revolvers Ever …. This is within the power of a heavily loaded. 44 Specials, it is easy to shoot and a great carry gun. 357 Mag is a much smaller diameter bullet than its. If you don’t own one, you should. For your training needs call Jeremy at tj young enterprises Perry Fla 850 838 7347. The 44 Mag's wider case accordingly seats a broader and heavier bullet - two factors that contribute heavily to the greater damage it can inflict. I still have it and a load of unique behind Keith's 245 SWC is going 9-950 FPS, is my 100 yard ring the metal plate load. A 44 special is lighter than the 357 chambered SAA. 44 is almost too much to handle when it comes to the same two criteria. These rifles are pretty much identical except one is chambered for. Bullet Diameter) 240 gr JHP 1,475 ft/s Velocity 1,160 ft-lbf The. I don't think I have ever heard the debate of the. The 44 Magnum is a slightly longer 44 Special that cannot be loaded into the 44 Special cylinder. I'm inclined to reccomend the 357 mag, but don't know much about the 44 sp capabilities. Lets take a look at a few numbers first. 44 Magnum could produce more muzzle velocity and energy, despite firing a heavier bullet. When Bears Attack — Top Sidearms to Carry in Bear Country. So, is bigger and slower as good or better than smaller and faster ? 357 Mag compared to 44 Special. 357 typically gets loaded with lighter rounds, as it is a smaller diameter. I would take a 357 Magnum with hard cast bullets over a standard 45 Colt round. Like the. 44 Special - in 'older' guns tends to be heavier. We thought the overall workmanship was very good, with no visible problems anywhere. I carry either my Ruger Alasken 44 mag, or my Ruger GP 100 in 44 Special with custom loaded 255 gr. Bullet Diameter) 210 gr JHP 1,560 ft/s Velocity 1,135 ft-lbf. 44 Magnum are some of the most iconic cartridges today. 357 you can get a buffalo bore, doubletap, or corbon hard-cast and gas. Lets look at factory loads for a minute with off the shelf loads that a typical shooter might find themselves with and not the handloader. 44spl will only be in an N frame unless it's a 5 shot; the K frame gives you 6, 7 in the L frame. ): PSI: 17 Rem-52,000 cup: 22 Hornet-25,000 CUP: 30-30 Winchester-42,000: 22 RF Short-21,000: 222 Remington-50,000: 303. The 44 Special can be used in the 44 Magnum cylinder with no problems. 357 Magnum snub nose. Yes, a max velocity 240gr hardcast SWC is NOT ideal for home defense. This is clearly more than enough power to penetrate and damage a target. 5 times faster than the. For the ballistic gel testing, I used synthetic gel blocks from Clear Ballistics. I would surmise, however, that a good percentage of those shootings were with the Charter Arms Bulldog, simply because they are a popular self defense revolver chambered in that round. As far as the 44 special/357 debate, I believe the 44 special would give a small edge due to the increased diameter of the bullet having a chance to cut an artery the smaller bullet might have missed. This lady is looking at a 5 shot 44 sp or a 357 snubby for a trail gun. Second, with just the criteria of. 44 Special will have less felt recoil than the. Properly loaded, a practiced marksman using the 8 3/8" barreled. When Bears Attack — Top Sidearms to Carry in Bear …. 357 is easier to shoot than the. 44 Magnum, and also less recoil while still being more than adequate for any situation. A box of 50 Federal American Eagle 158 grain 357 Magnum target loads will currently cost you $41. 44 Special - 357 Magnum Ammo. 357 makes up for the diameter of the. 44-40 to higher velocities than the 1,250 fps of the original blackpowder load is not a recent idea. Special: What I’ve Learned After 20,000 Rounds">. If you go with a 357 or 45 colt, you will have to buy specialty ammo to even be in the same ballpark as standard 44MAG ammo. 50 or so for premium hunting loads. 44 Special vs 44 Magnum: Caliber Comparison by Ammo. com/whoteewho Heavy Metal: / heavymetalpaul1 Impact ear. 357 Magnum vs. There's a reason used JM Marlin 1894s in 357 mag command higher prices and are harder to find. Neither cartridge is too intense when fired through N-Frame revolvers though. 3M views 11 years ago In this "basics" video I illustrate the difference between Magnum and Special cartridges, such as the. I don't think I have ever heard the debate of the. 44 Special vs the. 44 special on the other hand will give you 1032 for 591 foot pounds. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) Ammo Comparison. Obviously the 44 mag is a capable round, but it's too heavy a gun for her application. 44 Special (with other than the 'weak sister' factory loads) are both very capable calibers for self defense. The 44 Special went from 65% to 75% one shot stops, but the only table I could find didn't specify barrel length. 44 Remington Magnum – completely in the vein of Dirty Harry – still makes an excellent choice for the bear woods. 38 Special (Left) vs. This is both theory and my experience with a S&W 686 4" barrel and a 629 Mtn Gun, also with 4" barrel. 357 Magnum vs 44 Magnum – What’s Better for You?. 44 Special, it fell on hard times until the. , and it’s also easier on your wallet. A 44 special out of the "new" 44 specials Ruger is producing (44 on a 357 frame if I am correct) or one of the newer 357 magnum loads from Buffalo, Corbon, etc. Elmer Keith – the same one behind the 357 Magnum – developed the cartridge for hunting after years of handloading 44 Special cartridges with extra. 44 Special with good handloads and the right bullet will drop a deer. With a 3-inch barrel and a six-shot cylinder combining for a weight of just 25 ounces, this gun was made to be both carried and shot. Subscribe To American Handgunner. 357 Magnum rounds - on average - achieve a velocity of about 1290 feet per second (fps) while. 44 Snub Nose Revolvers Ever (Epic Carry. 357 with hard casts would be better in that scenario. 357 Magnum on the range because it is so easy to train new shooters on. 357 Magnum Round Then, as now, everyone wanted more powerful ammo. The 44 Magnum is based on the 44 Special cartridge. But something like the Speer Gold Dot 210gr JHP is an excellent choice. He encouraged major gun companies like Remington and Smith & Wesson to pick up the cartridge. 357, but you aren’t escaping with a box of. is slightly more expensive, ranging from about $1 each to $3. Highboy Click to expand No part of the problem is it's a rimmed cartridge which makes autoloading from a straight mag not as reliable. 44 Special (perfectly safe in an "N" frame S&W or a Ruger. Granted, the projectiles used in a 357, starting with 125 gr HP on up to 180 gr will vary a bit with the 44 cal 180 gr up to 240 gr bullets. 357 Magnum loads provide a snappy, more abrupt recoil sensation than does any factory load fired through the. 44 special you can get a 200 - 300 grain round pushing around 1000 FPS. 44spec vs 357 MAG Handguns: The Revolver Forum 44spec vs 357 MAG - The Firing Line Forums The Firing Line Forums> Hogan's Alley> Handguns: The Revolver Forum 44spec vs 357 MAG Forum Rules Firearms Safety Firearms Photos Links Library Lost Password Email Changes Register FAQ Calendar Today's Posts Search Search Forums Show Threads. 7 gr of VV N350 will clock you about 1173 fps. If I were limited to only one or the other, no debate at all--it's the. 3) The platform itself is smaller take the S&W K/L frame vs. The first major difference to note is that the 357 Mag is a rimmed cartridge while the 10mm cartridge is rimless. 44 special over the. 30-30: an early-1990s Winchester Model 1894 ‘Trapper’ with a 16. Let’s be clear: The 357 Mag and 44 Mag offer as great a range of ballistics as there are cartridges to choose from. 19th century British Webley "Bulldog. 357 Mag rounds carry less amount of energy compared to the. Assuming that we are talking about strong guns and cast bullet loads, the 357 mag is going to at it's best drive a 200 gr cast 1100-1200 fps out of a 4" barrel. 357 Mag and more than the. Not only the ammo is close to $1 a shot, you will also like to load it down to lighter loads so you can enjoy practicing with it. They have the same sights, same trigger. Assuming that we are talking about strong guns and cast bullet loads, the 357 mag is going to at it's best drive a 200 gr cast 1100-1200 fps out of a 4" barrel. 44 Special for self defense against black bear …. While these numbers don't sound like large numbers, consider the. 357, but you aren’t escaping with a box of. 5dB, representing 12 dB difference, or more than 10 time as much acoustic energy for the top end of the pistol spectrum. The 44 Special went from 65% to 75% one shot stops, but the only table I could find didn't specify barrel length. There is some overlap when you consider the magnums can fire their special counterparts (but. rifles, and the same applies to. That round starts with a tremendous amount of energy and it will do a lot a damage before it slows enough to stop penetrating. 357 mag but it possesses a lot more mass. 44 Special and the above loads fit the bill nicely. 357 Magnum the whole way. Energy Comparison : 44 Special and 357 Mag. The standard 44 Special loading pushes a 246 gr lead bullet at around 750 fps. loads are designed for hunting. Of course revolvers of this size offer more challenges for concealed carry. 44 special 180 gr XTP bullet with 10. 357? So which of these two is better? 12 gauge Aug 26, 2009 #8 Jimbo357mag Hawkeye Joined Feb 22, 2007. 38 Special cartridge and was first designed with a 158-grain semi-jacketed soft point (flat) bullet. 357 Mag rounds are any weak! Most of them will still be able to achieve an amount of energy as high as 500 ft. Given a similar gun and barrel length,. I would definitely try one out before buying. for less than a dollar per round. 44 might recoil lessesp if the gun. Far easier to shoot even with full magnum loads. There is some overlap when you consider the magnums can fire their special counterparts (but not vis-a-versa). 44-40 to higher velocities than the 1,250 fps of the original blackpowder load is not a recent idea. That's not to say it's ineffective. 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping power for self defense. 44 Magnum Ballistic Gel Tests Okay, let’s move on to the terminal ballistics. Shop 357 Magnum Ammo. For the 44 Spcl to be near that good, the load configuration needs to push the 44 spcl bullet a little faster than typical "light 44 special loads" and the bullet needs to be 240 grain. While it has been eclipsed by newer cartridges, the. 357 you can get a buffalo bore, doubletap, or corbon hard-cast and gas-checked round in 200 grains pushing 1200+ FPS. 44 is almost too much to handle when it comes to the same two criteria. 357 Magnum has a shorter parent cartridge which will chamber in guns made for the Magnum. This prevents the more powerful loads from damaging the 44 Special guns. When Bears Attack — Top Sidearms to Carry in Bear Country">When Bears Attack — Top Sidearms to Carry in Bear Country. When it comes to quality hunting ammo, the. 357 mag but it possesses a lot more mass. 44 special you can get a 200 - 300 grain round pushing around 1000 FPS. 44 Special will have less felt recoil than the. 44 Special projectile starts out a lot slower than the 125 gr. 357 Magnum and 44 Magnum are BY FAR the 2 most popular Magnum Ammunition Rounds. At a reasonable distance, with good shot placement and a good piece of. It should be noticed that this figure of 164. Gunfire Noise Level Reference Chart. 44 sp or 357 mag for bear?. , although a higher percentage of. I fired one round of each load with the handgun and one round with the rifle. With 44 Special, it's kicks like a mule on steroids. com%2fcomparison%2f357-vs-44/RK=2/RS=fkjq13f5p3Dny0SCIfEtMOjno7w-" referrerpolicy="origin" target="_blank">See full list on ammo. 5 foot-pounds of recoil, while the 357 mag is about 11. 44 Magnum cartridge in 1956. Given a similar gun and barrel length, the. Let’s be clear: The 357 Mag and 44 Mag offer as great a range of ballistics as there are cartridges to choose from. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) round averages out to about 500 ft-lb. The 357 magnum, depends on high velocity to to do it's work. 357 magnum vs 44 special round?. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) Ammo Comparison ">. lead round-nose bullet at a sleepy 750 f. It takes practice, but it can be accomplished quite routinely. This cartridge was and is still popular for its powerful performance and strength. 44 Special had about twice the stopping power of a. I had to buy 3 boxes of ammo and force myself to shoot it enough to get used to it. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps. Full-house magnums too much to handle?. 38 Special works fine in most. 357 Mag Vs. Ergo, they could tolerate more pressure. Until quite recently, the factory loads for the. Difference between a 44 magnum and a 44 special?. 357 is categorically less powerful in terms of available foot-pounds and bullet mass. 357 Magnum in suitable loads to be more 'snappy' in recoil and a bit harsher in report than the. There are low flash 357 rounds if you look around. 44 Special is considered a very accurate and versatile round and is well-suited for target. 357 S&W Magnum "the Mule" when it came to handgun hunting. 44 mag blackhawks, and I would. 44 Remington Magnum is suitable for use in revolver and lever-action rifles. 44 Magnum vs 357 Mag Cost. 44 Mag counterpart. 44 mag - Drywall Test - YouTube 0:00 / 10:33 Intro. 357 Magnum remains the most effective personal protection caliber of all. 44 Mag is much wider and voluminous cartridge that can hold more powder and withstand a higher amount of pressure when the powder is ignited. 44 Special vs. And a box of 20 Federal Hydra SHOK 44. ? I have a NIB Lipsey 44 special, but I had a Speed Six that I sold off years ago. But don't let that fool you into thinking that the. A Final Word On Bullets Bullet design has made tremendous strides in the past 15 to 20 years. 357 S&W Magnum can, and will, readily take most medium-sized game within 80-100 yards. A 357 would definitely be easier to carry, but I would go with a 44 mag. The 44 Magnum is based on the 44 Special cartridge. 357 Magnum pistol: a 1980s Smith & Wesson Model 686 with a 4″ barrel. Elmer Keith – the same one behind the 357 Magnum – developed the cartridge for hunting after years of handloading 44 Special cartridges with extra powder and heavier bullets. A Brace of Snubby 44 Specials: Taurus takes on Charter Arms. Factory ammo in 357 is also much cheaper than either 44 mag or 44 Special. It was evenly finished in matte black, with black-rubber finger-groove grips that fit our hands well. 357 for Concealed Carry By Combat Controller I was asked why someone would consider a. H andgun: PSI: R ifle: PSI: R ifle (Cont. 38 SPL has a very large following and materials can be had readily. 44 S&W Special Ammo Comparison. Granted, the projectiles used in a 357, starting with 125 gr HP on up to 180 gr will vary a bit with the 44 cal 180 gr up to 240 gr bullets. 357 mag vs 44spl from 2" barrel. You can’t load the right ammo for bear defense, but it’s better than a sharp stick. MidwayUSA currently lists 73 different. is about 20 percent less expensive. See more Reply Save Like Bob K · #4 · Aug 28, 2009. 44 S&W Special rounds travel at a velocity of 910 fps. 357 is less expensive both in the hunting and plinking categories. I'm inclined to reccomend the 357 mag, but don't know much about the 44 sp capabilities. 44 Special, it spends less. 44 S&W Special rounds travel at a velocity of 910 fps. This prevents the more powerful loads from damaging the 44 Special guns. 44 mag - Drywall Test WHO_TEE_WHO 491K subscribers 713K views 4 years ago Support us on Patreon. THIS video looks at the benefits of BOTH!Your support is critical to our mi. 357 Magnum carbin e: a new-production Marlin 1894C. Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a. 357 are fun and easy to use in a rifle, but the. 357 loads listed above provide impressive stopping power. On the other hand, I can shoot standard 357 mags in the 357 Marlin all afternoon long. 44 Special (with other than the 'weak sister' factory loads) are both very capable calibers for self defense. 44 Special for Rocky Mountains trail gun. 44 Special - the question is a bit of a non-starter. 357 Magnum, and either. 44 Special: It is a centerfire revolver cartridge developed by Smith & Wesson in 1907 as a black powder round. 44 Special is softer than a newborn kitten. For the 44 Spcl to be near that good, the load configuration needs to push the 44 spcl bullet a little faster than typical "light 44 special loads" and the bullet needs to be 240 grain. Elmer Keith suggested that the heavily loaded. Each round is available with a variety of bullet weights (357 Mag = 110 to 180 grains; 44 Mag = 180 to 300 grains), which contributes heavily to muzzle velocity. Safely loading the. These specifications gave gun owners the option for a hard-hitting and deep penetrating handgun cartridge, and that remains true to this day. Felt recoil is measured in foot-pounds (ft-lbs); the 44 mag is generally measured at 18. 45-70 is just as popular today as it was when it was first introduced in 1873. I'm inclined to reccomend the 357 mag, but don't know much about the 44 sp capabilities. This gives these guns marvelous flexibility in ammo selection. The round is based on the earlier Smith & Wesson. With a 3-inch barrel and a six-shot cylinder combining for a weight of just 25 ounces, this gun was made to be both carried and shot. Modern, high-performance projectiles will expand reliably at the comparatively low velocities produced by handguns. 357 will always be easier to shoot and generally more accurate. 44 Russian ammunition from Black Hills without a hitch. as others note, the 357 is so widely. The standard factory stuff for either the 357 or the 45colt will be way underpowered for bear protection. 44 mag blackhawks, and I would consider that. 357 Magnum vs. 357 Magnum, we noticed above that the. And a box of 20 Federal Hydra-Shok 357 Magnum rounds will be $35. The 44 sp will drive a 250 gr cast bullet 1000-1100 fps out of a 4" barrel. It uses slow burning powder to do this which is dependent on barrel length for a complete burn. While the case and overall length are similar, the. The standard 44 Special loading pushes a 246 gr lead bullet at around 750 fps. 44spec vs 357 MAG Handguns: The Revolver Forum 44spec vs 357 MAG - The Firing Line Forums The Firing Line Forums> Hogan's Alley> Handguns: The Revolver Forum 44spec vs 357 MAG Forum Rules Firearms Safety Firearms Photos Links Library Lost Password Email Changes Register FAQ Calendar Today's Posts Search Search Forums Show Threads. Mine weighed 21 ounces. So, it is clear as broad daylight that the. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) rounds travel at a velocity of 1050 fps. Magnum Melee: 357 vs 44 Magnum Calibers. 41 Special in those chambered. Once a popular bore size, and epitomized by the. It is not as handicapped by velocity loss in the snub barrel as the 357 magnum. 357 Magnum, The Better Cartridge. 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping power for self defense. Keep in mind I cut my handgun teeth on a S&W 29 44 magnum. Shortly after the Winchester Model 1892 was introduced, Winchester offered high-velocity. The rotary magazine of the bolt-action Ruger Model 77/44 in. It's a toss-up and neither would be considered ideal against a large predator. The only reason the 357 Magnum is not a preferred cartridge to a semi-auto pistol is ammo capacity. 44 special on the other hand will give you 1032 for 591 foot pounds. 44 Magnum is the most powerful cartridge among the three by far, having superior energy and muzzle velocity. 38 Special: What I’ve Learned After 20,000 Rounds. 357 Magnum carbin e: a new-production Marlin 1894C. When loaded the difference would be less though. The idea of. 44 Lipsey Special). A 44 special out of the "new" 44 specials Ruger is producing (44 on a 357 frame if I am correct) or one of the newer 357 magnum loads from Buffalo, Corbon, etc. The 44 Magnum is based on the 44 Special cartridge. 44 Special, $414 This is the latest version of the popular Charter Bulldog. is just as easy-handling, faster and more powerful in every way. 357 Magnum, a 125gr JHP performs MUCH differently on a person than a 158gr JSP. They have been embedded in American history and culture. Obviously the 44 mag is a capable round, but it's too heavy a gun for her application. 357 is categorically less powerful in terms of available foot-pounds and bullet mass. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels. 44 Remington Magnum – completely in. com/_ylt=AwrFNx1VsGFkgCwzrZ9XNyoA;_ylu=Y29sbwNiZjEEcG9zAzIEdnRpZAMEc2VjA3Ny/RV=2/RE=1684152533/RO=10/RU=https%3a%2f%2fammo. It will not slow down as quickly when it encounters resistance simply due to its great mass. 44 magnum and a 44 special?. While plenty of gun guys (and gals) scoff at shooters who complain about recoil, it can have a major effect on accuracy. 357 you can get a buffalo bore, doubletap, or corbon hard-cast and gas-checked round in 200 grains pushing 1200+ FPS. 44 Special on whitetail deer. The Rim Diameter of this cartridge is. 44 Special have been pretty anemic—a 246-gr. Is this making sense - yet ? Reply Save Like firescout · #7 · Dec 25, 2016 oldag said:. The 44 Magnum is a slightly longer 44 Special that cannot be loaded into the 44 Special cylinder. The standard 1894 in 44 mag is no cream puff when it comes to recoil. 44 Special have been pretty anemic—a 246-gr. 357 Magnum on whitetail deer. 357 mag does have a very good track record in actual shootings and there are a few rounds that stand above the rest in terms of effectiveness (the 125 grain, semi-jacketed, semi-waddcutter hollow point made by Federal comes to mind). Each block is 16 inches long and I lined up two of them longways. 357 mag vs 45 colt for black bears. 41 Magnum was designed in 1964. The 44 Special can be used in the 44 Magnum cylinder with no problems. My choice would ALWAYS be the larger caliber, with the correct bullet and heavy loads. 44 Special for Everyday Workin’ Loads is a relatively lightweight sixgun, around 1/2 lb. Lets look at factory loads for a minute with off the shelf loads. 32 Win Special-42,000: 32 S&W Long-15,000: 223 WSSM- 357 Magnum-35,000: 270 WSM-65,000: 8mm Mauser- 44 Remington Mag-36,000: 7mm Mauser-51,000: 375 H & H-. 44 Special for self defense against black bear and moose I go camping frequently up in Maine and New Hampshire. That gives us an even playing field for our ammo testing. 44 Magnum, and also less recoil while still being more than adequate for any situation which should arise. 357 is usually 10-20% less expensive. 1) You can go from light. Felt recoil is measured in foot-pounds (ft-lbs); the 44 mag is generally measured at 18. 357 is easier to shoot than the. That round starts with a tremendous amount of energy and it will do a lot a damage before it slows enough to stop penetrating. 357 Magnum round averages out to 530 ft-lb, while a. 357 Magnum and the other for. 44 Remington Magnum hit the scene. 357 magnum for carry or general defense. Best Ammo : 357 Mag vs 44 Mag : Battle For Number One!. 357 Magnum in suitable loads to be more 'snappy' in recoil and a bit harsher in report than the. This difference showcases the design intention for both cartridges as the 10mm was designed for use in a semi-automatic pistol while the. 44 Special had about twice the stopping power of a. 44 Magnum are some of the most iconic. Now that I've finally been able to get my hands on. This ammo has diverse use ranging from target shooting to self-defense and hunting. 357, but you aren't escaping with a box of. The 44 spl offers big bore performance without the flash and concussion of the 357 mag. A 44 special was my first Colt SAA over 30 years ago in a 3rd generation 5 1/2. There is almost no recoil and the student can increase power level when they feel ready using the same gun. When I go, I always bring my four lovely Smiths. The 44 Mag's case is nearly the same length as the 357 Mag's, but its greater diameter gives it approximately 45 percent more capacity for propellant. I wouldn't feel undergunned with it. i think both are really excellent rounds. But what about a good 170 grain SWC moving at 1,300 fps from the. If fired from the same platform, and using "standard" factory loads, the. The only reason the 357 Magnum is not a preferred cartridge to a semi-auto pistol is ammo capacity. 44 special is a good man stopper. As far as the 44 special/357 debate, I believe the 44 special would give.